The Holiday Guilt Tax: Nearly 40% of Gen Z Are Buying Holiday Gifts for People They Don't Even Like
Source: PR NewswireView original on PR Newswire
1 in 5 Americans overall plan to buy gifts for people they dislike, with nearly half of reluctant gift-givers shelling out $200 or more to keep up appearances
The emotional cost of holiday expectations reveals almost 80% report some guilt-driven gift-giving, 62% of Gen Z are caught in a holiday spending spiral, and nearly 40% of Americans say spending pressure is stealing their holiday cheer
CHICAGO, Nov. 17, 2026 /PRNewswire/ -- 'Tis the season of giving, even to people you're not particularly fond of. A new survey commissioned by Beyond Finance finds that nearly 40% of Gen Z (38%) plan to buy holiday gifts for people they don't even like, simply because they feel obligated. Across all generations, 1 in 5 Americans (20%) say the same. And keeping up appearances isn't cheap. Among those buying gifts for people they dislike, nearly half plan to spend $200 or more on those gifts.
When Gift-Giving Becomes an Obligation
The survey of 2,000 U.S. adults who celebrate a winter holiday reveals how guilt, social pressure, and financial anxiety are turning gift-giving into an obligation, fueling a cycle of emotional spending that's stealing the joy from the holiday season.
"We're calling it the Holiday Guilt Tax: That extra money people spend, not because they want to, but because they feel they have to," said Dr. Erika Rasure, chief financial wellness advisor at Beyond Finance. "When you're buying gifts for people you don't even like, that's not generosity. That's obligation."
The pressure extends far beyond buying gifts for people you dislike. Among respondents who answered a question about gift-giving motivations, 79% report that at least some of their holiday gift-giving is motivated by guilt, shame, pressure, or obligation, while 27% say those emotions drive all of their gift-giving.
Younger Americans are particularly likely to participate in reluctant gift-giving:
Generation | Plan to buy gifts for people they don't like |
Gen Z | 38 % |
Millennials | 28 % |
Gen X | 17 % |
Baby boomers | 8 % |
These findings reveal how social expectations can turn holiday shopping into an expensive exercise in keeping up appearances.
Gen Z Is Caught in the Holiday Spending Spiral
The Holiday Guilt Tax is just one symptom of a broader problem: the holiday spending spiral.
Nearly two-thirds of Gen Z (62%) report experiencing a holiday spending spiral, characterized by emotional or social pressure, poor financial planning, or spending that feels difficult to control.
Overall, 35% of Americans report experiencing a holiday spending spiral, including:
- Gen Z: 62%
- Millennials: 47%
- Gen X: 34%
- Baby boomers: 17%
The survey also reveals differences in how men and women experience holiday spending. Men report experiencing a spending spiral at higher rates than women (41% vs. 32%), while women report higher levels of holiday shopping anxiety (22% vs. 17%).
"The holiday spending spiral often starts with a simple thought: 'I have to buy this because it's expected of me,'" said Dr. Rasure. "One purchase becomes another, and suddenly people are spending to manage guilt rather than because they genuinely want to give."
Holiday Spending Pressure Is Stealing the Joy
For many Americans, holiday spending expectations are taking an emotional toll. Nearly four in 10 (38%) say spending pressure is stealing their holiday cheer, while 17% say financial stress has reduced their enjoyment of the season.
The pressure is also affecting social connections and mental health:
- 13% have avoided holiday gatherings because they couldn't afford to participate.
- 11% report feeling isolated or lonely because of holiday financial pressure.
- 22% of Gen Z report isolation or loneliness, compared with 4% of baby boomers.
- 21% of Gen Z report a negative mental health impact, compared with 3% of baby boomers.
"When the pressure to spend starts affecting your relationships, your mental health, and your ability to enjoy the season, it's time to rethink what the holidays are really about," said Dr. Rasure.
How to Avoid the Holiday Guilt Tax
Beyond Finance encourages consumers to recognize the emotional triggers behind holiday spending and set boundaries that protect both their finances and their well-being.
That means having honest conversations about gift expectations, agreeing on spending limits, suggesting group exchanges, or simply giving yourself permission to skip purchases driven by guilt.
"You don't have to buy someone's approval, and you don't have to spend money to prove you care," added Dr. Rasure. "The holidays should strengthen relationships — not leave people feeling trapped by expectations."
About the Survey
Talker Research conducted a random double-opt-in survey of 2,000 U.S. adults aged 18 and older who celebrate a winter holiday, October 16–20, 2026, on behalf of Beyond Finance.
About Dr. Erika Rasure
Dr. Erika Rasure, PhD, CFT™ is a nationally recognized financial therapist, educator, and researcher with over two decades of experience helping people transform their relationship with money. She holds a doctorate in Personal Financial Planning from Kansas State University and is a Certified Financial Therapist™ — one of a small number of practitioners in the country to hold both credentials. As Chief Financial Wellness Advisor at Beyond Finance, she leads five weekly financial wellness sessions with clients navigating debt and is the creator of Beyond Finance's Financial Wellness RESET™ Framework, Assessment, and Curriculum — a proprietary, clinically-informed model that addresses the behavioral and emotional reasons financial advice so often fails to stick, helping people change not just what they do with money, but how they relate to it. She serves on the Financial Review Boards of Investopedia, The Balance, VeryWell Family, and VeryWell Parents, chairs the Financial Therapy Clinical Institute Research Board, and her expertise has been featured on NBC's Today Show, CNBC, CNN, Forbes, the Wall Street Journal, Fortune, Barron's, the Associated Press, and USA Today.
About Beyond Finance
Beyond Finance is a leading financial wellness and debt consolidation company that has helped more than 1.3 million Americans, and resolved over $15 billion in client debt since 2011. Beyond Finance's financial wellness programming includes the Financial Wellness RESET™ Framework — a proprietary, clinically-informed model developed by Dr. Erika Rasure that addresses the behavioral and emotional dimensions of financial change alongside the practical ones — alongside five weekly live financial wellness sessions led by certified financial therapists, available to all enrolled clients.
Beyond Finance holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and has received recognition, including the Organization of the Year award from The Business Intelligence Group's Excellence in Customer Service Award, the Gold Stevie Award for Outstanding Customer Service Department, the Banking Tech Award for Financial Wellness Champion, the Best In Biz Gold Award, and three ConsumerAffairs Buyer's Choice Awards. Beyond Finance has offices in Chicago and Houston.
For more information, visit BeyondFinance.com.
View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/the-holiday-guilt-tax-nearly-40-of-gen-z-are-buying-holiday-gifts-for-people-they-dont-even-like-302942356.html
Source: PR NewswireView original on PR Newswire
Content provided by PR Newswire. Redistribution, resale or sublicensing is not permitted.